Supreme Court Rejects Student Loan Bankruptcy Case, Leavinq Harsh Standard Intact for Now

July 14, 2021

The United States Supreme Court has refused to hear a case raising questions about whether student loans can be discharged in bankruptcy, leaving a tough student loan bankruptcy standard in place for the time being.

The case, Conti v. Arrowood Indemnity Co., involved a borrower who was trying to discharge her private student loans in bankruptcy. Conti, the borrower, had attended the University of Michigan and took out private student loans from Citibank totaling over $76,000. The loan applications identified the debt as educational debt for “students attending 4-year colleges and universities,” and the promissory notes mandated that “the proceeds of this loan are to be used for specific educational expenses.” The loans were disbursed directly to the university, and none of the disbursements exceeded the total cost of attendance.

In 2017, Conti filed for bankruptcy and listed the Citibank loans as dischargeable. But the bankruptcy code treats student loans very differently from most other forms of consumer debt, such as credit cards or past due bills. To discharge student loans in bankruptcy, borrowers must generally prove that they have an “undue hardship,” which is a difficult standard to meet. These restrictions initially only applied to federal student loans, but were subsequently expanded to cover private student loans (like Conti’s) following the passage of a 2005 bankruptcy reform bill.

The “undue hardship” standard is not well-defined in statute, so bankruptcy courts have established several tests, which vary by circuit, to determine whether a borrower can meet the standard. But to even try to show that they meet the “undue hardship” standard, student loan borrowers must initiate an “adversary proceeding,” which is essentially a lawsuit within the bankruptcy case that is brought against the applicable lenders. The adversary proceeding can be a long and invasive process for borrowers, and can get quite expensive for those who retain a private attorney. Student loan lenders may also have significantly more resources than borrowers, which can give them an advantage. As a result, many student loan borrowers are unsuccessful in proving undue hardship, and many others don’t even try.

Conti filed an adversary proceeding not to show that she met the “undue hardship” standard for student loans, however. Instead, she filed an adversary proceeding to try to show that the private student loans were not “qualified education loans” within the meaning of the bankruptcy code due to questions and disputes about the exact cost of attendance, her status as a student, and her other applicable financial aid. If successful, this strategy would have allowed her to potentially bypass the “undue hardship” standard altogether.

However, the bankruptcy court rejected her arguments, and a federal district court and the federal Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed. The Sixth Circuit concluded that the plain language of the loan application and promissory notes clearly showed that these were student loans and, thus, were not dischargeable in bankruptcy, absent a showing of undue hardship.

Conti appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court. But by rejecting the case today, the Court has effectively kept the tough bankruptcy code’s treatment of student loans in place.

Ultimately, when it comes to student loans and bankruptcy, it may take action by Congress for there to be real reform. Earlier this year, Senate Democrats unveiled the Medical Bankruptcy Fairness Act of 2021, which would allow student loan borrowers to discharge their student debt in bankruptcy without having to prove undue hardship. The bill would make a simple change to the bankruptcy code by simply eliminating the section that treats student loan debt differently.

Congressional Democrats have proposed similar bills in the past, but those proposals went nowhere in the Republican-controlled Senate. Now, with Democrats holding narrow majorities in both chambers of Congress, bankruptcy reform has a better chance of passing. But, it is unclear if student loan bankruptcy reform would garner sufficient bipartisan support to overcome a potential Republican filibuster.

Why Choose Jacoby & Jacoby?

Experienced and Qualified Representation

When you work with a New York bankruptcy lawyer at Jacoby & Jacoby, you have the benefit of our years of experience and our extensive resources, all at your disposal as you face these trying times. The stress and emotions associated with mounting debt may leave you feeling hopeless and lost. Thankfully, with the help of a lawyer at our firm, you can begin to take control of your finances and experience much needed relief.

By discussing your situation with an attorney at our firm, you can decide whether bankruptcy is right for you. You can learn what your options are. When you work with an experienced attorney at Jacoby & Jacoby, you will have the support and legal counsel of a professional who will know what to do to help. Finally, you can experience relief from creditors. You can stop worrying about losing your possessions or your home.

Contact our firm today, and learn more about the many ways that we can come to your aid. Call Jacoby & Jacoby at (888)452-2629.

  • NACBA logo
  • NYSBA logo
  • SCBA logo
  • NYSTLA logo

Schedule a Free Consultation

Schedule your FREE bankruptcy evaluation at (888)452-2629

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

  • Suffolk County Offices

  • Medford Main Office

    1737 North Ocean Avenue
    Medford, NY 11763


  • Shirley Office

    450 William Floyd Parkway, Suite B
    Shirely, NY 11967


  • Bohemia Office

    80 Orville Drive, Suite 100
    Bohemia, NY 11716


  • Hauppauge Office

    150 Motor Parkway, Suite 401
    Hauppauge, NY 11788


  • Melville Office

    200 Broadhollow Road, Ste. 207
    Melville, NY 11747


  • Riverhead Office

    30 West Main Street
    Riverhead, NY 11901


  • Nassau County Offices

  • East Meadow Main Office

    2545 Hempstead Turnpike, Suite 304
    East Meadow, NY 11554


  • Uniondale Office

    626 Rexcorp. Plaza
    Uniondale, NY 11553


  • Valley Stream Office

    70 East Sunrise Highway, Suite 500
    Valley Stream, NY 11581


  • Queens Office

    Mercury Center
    9-10 Main Street, Suite 300
    Flushing, NY 11354


  • Lake Success Office

    1979 Marcus Avenue, Suite 210E, Lake Success, NY 11020


"We are a designated debt relief agency under Federal Law & we provide legal assistance to consumers seeking relief under the Bankruptcy Code".